Skip main navigation

Natalie Clayton

(She/Her/Hers)
Maywright Property Co.

Recent Sales

Skip to the end of the carousel
  • $795,000
    5 bd4 ba3936 sqft Indianapolis, IN
    5 bd4 ba3936 sqft
    Indianapolis, IN
    Sold 24 days ago
    Seller
    2021 Carrollton Ave, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
  • $310,000
    3 bd2 ba1648 sqft Indianapolis, IN
    3 bd2 ba1648 sqft
    Indianapolis, IN
    Sold 24 days ago
    Buyer
    8305 Warbler Way, Indianapolis, IN, 46256
  • $227,500
    2 bd2 ba1584 sqft Indianapolis, IN
    2 bd2 ba1584 sqft
    Indianapolis, IN
    Sold 24 days ago
    Seller
    5455 E 13th St, Indianapolis, IN, 46219
  • $691,000
    4 bd4 ba3062 sqft Indianapolis, IN
    4 bd4 ba3062 sqft
    Indianapolis, IN
    Sold 24 days ago
    Buyer
    548 N Highland Ave, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
  • $415,000
    4 bd6 ba- - Indianapolis, IN
    4 bd6 ba- -
    Indianapolis, IN
    Sold 1 month ago
    Seller
    1613 Nowland Ave, Indianapolis, IN, 46201
Skip to the beginning of the carousel
43
Sales last 12 months
362
Total sales
$49K-$935K
Price range
$381K
Average price

Get to know Natalie Clayton

Founder and Broker

Specialties
Buyer's AgentListing AgentStagingProperty ManagementVacation / Short-term RentalsInvestment PropertiesRentals

Natalie Clayton's listings & sales (366)

For Sale
For Rent
Sold
This map can show the most recent 100 listings and 100 sales. Review all listings and sales below.

For Sale (4)

Sold (362)

Natalie Clayton's reviews (32)

Write a review
  • Highly likely to recommend5.05.0

    3/5/2025 - waaron77062
    Sold a Single Family home in 2025 in Near eastside, Indianapolis, IN.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    Natalie was the BEST. Clear prompt communication. Easy to work with. Natalie was a great advocate. She helped us sell our near east side/Springdale home that had been on the market for months prior to switching realtors. Highly recommended!
  • Highly likely to recommend5.05.0

    1/5/2025 - lkenny317
    Bought a Single Family home in 2025 in Zionsville, IN.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    As first-time homebuyers, we couldn’t have asked for a better realtor than Natalie! From our first conversation, she supported us every step of the way. When we found a house we loved, she immediately jumped in to help us put in an offer the same day... 
  • Highly likely to recommend5.05.0

    12/17/2024 - Elias Khalil
    Sold a Single Family home in 2024 in Near northside, Indianapolis, IN.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    It was great working with Natalie and her team on the sale of our house. Super responsive, kind and pragmatic. Her team is super efficient, very precise and works in a synchronized manner… Natalie delivered on expectations and more. We will work with... 
  • Highly likely to recommend5.05.0

    10/29/2024 - zuser20160801185406969
    Bought a home in 2022.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    I found the house of my dreams, despite it looking nothing like my original search parameters and Natalie leveraged her understanding of real estate process, her negotiation skills, and her relationships to ensure I secured the house of my dreams. No... 
  • Will never recommend1.01.0

    9/25/2024 - indypoolpatrol317
    Property managed a home I rent.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    I was informed, after being approved for a rental property and providing the proper documentation for reasonable accommodation for my service animal, that there was a breed restriction for my service animal. I informed the owner, Natalie Clayton, of ... 

    Response from Natalie Clayton on 10/1/2024

    Steve, I'm sorry you feel this way; I appreciate your prompt information and education on service animals (this is not something I've encountered as a private landlord). While I recognize I did ask what breed your service animal was - and that was not allowed per Fair Housing, I disagree with the other details you've shared here. Once you directed me to Fair Housing information, I immediately contacted an attorney to educate myself on the matter. I also NEVER denied you the option to rent. Instead, I not only approved your application, but I sent you a boilerplate lease to be sure you were comfortable with the terms; I also outlined all financial items in an email with the boilerplate lease prior to customizing the lease because I wanted to be sure you wished to move forward. I never asked you to fill in the lease. I never asked you for a $300 administrative fee (you may be confusing me with someone else). And Zillow does not have a space to note a cleaning fee - but I was very upfront with this, as it is part of the boilerplate lease. I, too, have all of our conversations saved, so I'm happy to provide those, as unfortunately, there are many untruths to your review. I do hope you find safe and comfortable housing; I work hard to provide this for all of my tenants - and often at below market rate. Thanks for your time, Steve.

Service areas (4)

Natalie Clayton

(She/Her/Hers)
Maywright Property Co.
43sales last 12 months
362total sales
$49K-$935Kprice range
$381Kaverage price