Skip main navigation
Active
$587,500
5beds
3,771sqft

623 W Milroy Ave, Rensselaer, IN 47978

5beds
3,771sqft
Single family residence
Built in 1893
0.60 Acres
2 Garage spaces
$156 price/sqft

What's special

Gorgeous sunroomOriginal victorian pondIntricate trimCozy family roomWide front porchExquisite architectural detailsAbundant natural light

Welcome to one of the most admired Victorian homes on Milroy Ave. -- rich in history, unforgettable charm, and thoughtfully updated for the way we live today. Built in 1893, this 3-story treasure offers approximately 3,770 SF of distinctive character on just over 1/2 acre, framed by mature trees and a ...

63 days
|
578
|
17
|
Source: NIRA,MLS#: 830333MLS Logo
Travel times

Living Room

Kitchen

Primary Bedroom

Zillow last checked: 8 hours ago

Listing updated: November 06, 2025 at 10:27am

Listed by:

Terri Phegley,

Cornerstone Real Estate Agency 219-866-4528

Source: NIRA,MLS#: 830333MLS Logo

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms & bathrooms
  • Bedrooms: 5
  • Bathrooms: 4
  • Full bathrooms: 1
  • 3/4 bathrooms: 2
  • 1/2 bathrooms: 1
Rooms
  • Room types: Bedroom 2, Other Room, Primary Bedroom, Living Room, Library, Kitchen, Family Room, Dining Room, Bedroom 5, Bedroom 4, Bedroom 3
Primary bedroom
  • Description: 3/4 Bath
  • Area: 414
  • Dimensions: 23.0 x 18.0
Bedroom 2
  • Description: 2 - Closets - One is a walk in
  • Area: 169
  • Dimensions: 13.0 x 13.0
Bedroom 3
  • Area: 120
  • Dimensions: 12.0 x 10.0
Bedroom 4
  • Description: Pocket Doors
  • Area: 195
  • Dimensions: 15.0 x 13.0
Bedroom 5
  • Description: Pocket Doors, Decorative Fireplace
  • Area: 168
  • Dimensions: 14.0 x 12.0
Dining room
  • Description: Built in Buffet
  • Area: 242
  • Dimensions: 22.0 x 11.0
Family room
  • Description: 3/4 Bath
  • Area: 169
  • Dimensions: 13.0 x 13.0
Foyer
  • Area: 42
  • Dimensions: 7.0 x 6.0
Kitchen
  • Description: Refrigerator, Gas Stove, Open to sunlit dining area with window seat
  • Area: 132
  • Dimensions: 12.0 x 11.0
Library
  • Description: 1/2 Bath
  • Area: 162
  • Dimensions: 13.5 x 12.0
Living room
  • Description: Decorative Original Fireplace, Inlaid hardwood floors
  • Area: 221
  • Dimensions: 17.0 x 13.0
Other
  • Description: Parlor/Sitting Room with Pocket Doors, Inlaid hardwood floors
  • Area: 196
  • Dimensions: 14.0 x 14.0
Other
  • Description: Dining Area with gorgeous windows and window seat
  • Area: 266
  • Dimensions: 19.0 x 14.0
Other
  • Description: Second Floor Landing
  • Area: 128
  • Dimensions: 16.0 x 8.0
Sunroom
  • Description: Sleeping Porch with gorgeous windows
  • Area: 242
  • Dimensions: 22.0 x 11.0
Heating
  • ENERGY STAR Qualified Equipment, Zoned, Natural Gas, Forced Air
Appliances
  • Included: Refrigerator
  • Laundry: Lower Level
Features
  • Ceiling Fan(s), Walk-In Closet(s), Recessed Lighting, Open Floorplan, Laminate Counters, High Ceilings, Entrance Foyer
  • Basement: Interior Entry,Unfinished,Storage Space
  • Number of fireplaces: 3
  • Fireplace features: Family Room, Other, Living Room
Interior area
  • Total structure area: 3,771
  • Total interior livable area: 3,771 sqft
  • Finished area above ground: 3,771
Video & virtual tour

Property

Parking
  • Total spaces: 2
  • Parking features: Garage Door Opener, Driveway, Concrete, Additional Parking
  • Garage spaces: 2
  • Has uncovered spaces: Yes
Features
  • Levels: Three Or More
  • Patio & porch: Covered, Front Porch, Deck
  • Exterior features: Fire Pit, Private Yard, Other
  • Pool features: Above Ground
  • Fencing: Back Yard
  • Has view: Yes
  • View description: Neighborhood
Lot
  • Size: 0.6 Acres
  • Features: Back Yard, Rectangular Lot, Private, Front Yard
Details
  • Parcel number: 370730000114000027
  • Special conditions: None

Construction

Type & style
  • Home type: SingleFamily
  • Property subtype: Single Family Residence
Condition
  • New construction: No
  • Year built: 1893

Utilities & green energy

  • Sewer: Public Sewer
  • Water: Public
  • Utilities for property: Electricity Connected, Water Connected, Sewer Connected, Natural Gas Connected

Community & HOA

Community
  • Subdivision: Rensselaer
HOA
  • Has HOA: No
Location
  • Region: Rensselaer

Financial & listing details

  • Price per square foot: $156/sqft
  • Tax assessed value: $288,300
  • Annual tax amount: $1,823
  • Date on market: 11/4/2025
  • Listing agreement: Exclusive Agency
  • Listing terms: Conventional,VA Loan,FHA

Price history

DateEventPrice
11/4/2025Listed for sale$587,500+217.6%$156/sqft
Source: NIRA #830333
10/30/2008Sold$185,000$49/sqft
Source: Agent Provided

Public tax history

YearProperty taxesTax assessment
2024$1,694 -3.8%$288,300 +4%
2023$1,761 -1.6%$277,200 +7%
2022$1,790 +7.4%$259,000 +5.7%

Find assessor info on the county website

BuyAbility℠ payment

Est. payment
$2,724/mo
Principal & interest
$2278
Property taxes
$240
Home insurance
$206

    Estimated market value

    $531,000 - $587,000

    $559,000

    $2,494/mo

    Climate risks

    Explore flood, wildfire, and other predictive climate risk information for this property on First Street®️.

    Nearby schools

    GreatSchools rating