48 Garden St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Set on one of Sag Harbor Village's most coveted streets, this reimagined 1890s traditional blends privacy with effortless access to in-town living. Preserving its original 1890 front façade, the home was fully rebuilt in 2008 using modern construction techniques and classic materials, like wide-plank hardwood floors reclaimed from an antique barn. It was exquisitely renovated again in 2024/2025 to introduce refined, contemporary design. The main level begins with an entry hall and powder room, leading past two guest bedrooms with a shared full bath to a sun-filled living room anchored by a gas fireplace. The open kitchen and dining area is a chef's dream, featuring custom cabinetry and top-tier appliances. A gabled clerestory window floods the space with natural light, and a mudroom with laundry opens to the private, landscaped backyard and bluestone patio, offering a true sense of escape. Upstairs, the expansive primary suite features a sitting area, built-in cabinetry, walk-in closet, and a spa-like bath with double vanities, an oversized shower with dual rain heads, and bench seating. The detached garage has been exquisitely transformed with custom finishes into a versatile accessory structure, ideal as a studio, home office, or entertaining space, framed by a firepit and al fresco dining area for seamless outdoor living. A turnkey opportunity in a premier Village location, just blocks from Main Street, restaurants, shops, marinas, the movie theater, gyms, and the Jitney.