18 Oak Ave, Island Heights, NJ 08732

Serene Porch Living & Water Views in Island Heights (Working with buyer agents) Tucked in the storybook riverside village of Island Heights, this beautifully restored Dutch colonial blends historic charm with refined modern living. Located just steps from the shimmering waters of the Toms River, this five-bedroom, 2.5-bath gem invites you to live your dream life by the water - with picturesque views from every floor. Boasting one of the town’s most attractive and functional front porches, enjoy the recent high-quality restoration with Ipe Brazilian hardwood decking, custom mahogany posts and railings, and a clear cedar ceiling—you’ll enjoy the daily sea breeze, friendly neighborhood conversations, and amazing views of the water. The porch’s weatherproof Azek board and batten side panels ensure beauty and durability in every season. Imagine sipping morning coffee as sails glide by or enjoying evening sunsets that set the river ablaze. This is what we call “porch living!” But it’s Wednesday nights in Island Heights that truly shine, when local sailors take to the river in a spectacle of fluttering sails and golden light all summer season—a cherished tradition you can enjoy from the porch, bay windows, or third story master suite. Inside, the home unfolds across three levels of thoughtfully renovated living space, featuring: > A bright and airy open floor plan on the first floor. > A second floor offering 3 bedrooms, hall closet, and full bath with stacked washer/dryer to conserve space. > Spacious third-floor master suite with large bedroom, separate office or fifth bedroom, and bathroom with recently renovated two-head shower. > 3-zone central air > gas fireplace > Hardwood floors throughout > Colonial craftsman trim work > Attic storage > And more. The backyard sanctuary is a dream come true: a paver patio and elevated deck overlook lush, low-maintenance planting beds, and fully enclosed by a custom cedar fence. A cleverly concealed bike locker beneath the deck keeps outdoor gear tucked away, while the tidy lawn offers just enough green space for kids and pets without the upkeep. Outside access to a basement offers additional storage space, a custom workbench, and slop sink for project cleanup. Also enjoy a 2-car driveway for off-street parking. The home is just steps from the river and local boardwalk, which features a two-story pavilion and separate pier for sunset views or crabbing. The historic Island Heights Yacht Club, renowned for its sailing culture and social event calendar, also sits in front of member available boat slips at the end of the street. You will also be in perfect proximity to the town’s local Sailfest street fair each September, along with lots of local events at waterfront Wannamaker Field, Peto Museum, firehouse, and more. The town of Island Heights is its own municipality with its own local police force to ensure the safety of the community. The town also boasts a Blue Ribbon K-6 school within walking distance of any residence. This is not just a house—it’s a lifestyle. A place where neighbors still converse from porch to porch, where community friends walk by to visit, where local art and sailing flourish, and where timeless architecture meets waterside serenity.