Skip main navigation
  • 59 Watchogue Ave

    East Moriches, NY 11940

    Apartment building
    2-3 beds

    Available units

    This building may have units for rent or for sale. Select a unit to contact.
    $769,000
    2 bd, 2 ba
    1,200 sqft
    For sale - Unit 3

    Listing by: Signature Homes of New York

    $825,000
    2 bd, 2 ba
    1,200 sqft
    Pending - Unit 41

    Listing by: Points East Real Estate

    What's special

    Rental Registration #: PHRL354658 Villas on the Bay, a very sought after community sited on the quiet waters of Harts Cove with magnificent vistas onto Moriches Bay and beyond to the Atlantic. This upper end-unit with 2 bedrooms, 2 baths, one an en-suite, living room, dining area, kitchen with plenty of storage, a washer and dryer in the unit, and a huge deck overlooks paradise. The second level has a loft space and den, or what your needs might be. The main floor has vaulted ceilings and because it is an end unit there are fabulous views of the woods and the pond on the community's multi-acre property. There is a one car garage and basement in tandem. The amenities at Villas on the Bay include two tennis and pickleball courts, a heated gunite 50' pool, chaises and tables for your convenience and a shaded canopy. The wildlife is spectacular with many species of birds, Blue Heron, Cranes, and many other beautiful bird life, including the 2 swans that have made their home on the waters at the Villas. Spectacular sunrises are right outside your windows and sliders. The enjoyment of nature and beautiful glistening water offers an abundance of serenity and privacy. A perfect year round rental, bring your own furniture and settle into a restorative lifestyle

    Neighborhood: 11940

    Skip to the end of the carousel
    • Beach Access
      Easy coastal access for swimming, sunbathing, and seaside relaxation.
      Outdoor Activities
      Ample parks and spaces for hiking, biking, and active recreation.
      Community Vibe
      Strong neighborhood connections and community events foster a friendly atmosphere.
      Suburban Calm
      Serene suburban setting with space, comfort, and community charm.
    Skip to the beginning of the carousel

    East Moriches (11940) is a bayside hamlet on Long Island’s South Shore, edged by Moriches Bay and salt marshes, with four true seasons and cooling ocean breezes in summer. The vibe is small‑town maritime—think marinas, clamming, and quiet streets—anchored by a proud Coast Guard history tied to the Hindenburg rescue. It feels friendly and low‑key, with parks and green spaces that make it welcoming for families and pets. Daily life centers on Montauk Highway with local cafes and bagel spots, farm stands, and nearby groceries like King Kullen in Center Moriches, plus the Moriches Shopping Center; you’re minutes to Terrell River County Park trails, Kaler’s Pond Nature Center, and beach days at Cupsogue. Kayaking, paddleboarding, and boating are weekend staples; yoga studios and fitness options sit in Center Moriches and Westhampton, with a casual dining scene and seasonal festivals close by. Sunrise Highway/NY‑27 provides swift access to jobs west or Hamptons east, and recent Zillow market trends show the median asking rent in the low–mid $3,000s, with most rentals roughly $2,500–$4,500 in recent months.

    Powered by Zillow data and AI technology.

    Areas of interest

    Use our interactive map to explore the neighborhood and see how it matches your interests.

    Travel times

    Walk, Transit & Bike Scores

    7 / 100
    Car-Dependent
    27 / 100
    Somewhat Bikeable

    Nearby schools in East Moriches

    GreatSchools rating

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the walk score of 59 Watchogue Ave?

    59 Watchogue Ave has a walk score of 7, it's car-dependent.

    What schools are assigned to 59 Watchogue Ave?

    The schools assigned to 59 Watchogue Ave include East Moriches Elementary School and East Moriches School.

    What neighborhood is 59 Watchogue Ave in?

    59 Watchogue Ave is in the 11940 neighborhood in East Moriches, NY.