2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom - 2nd Floor - Above Shops.
Welcome to beautiful St. James. Walk to LIRR Railroad, Supermarket, Laundromat, Dry Cleaner, Drug Store, Bakery, Bagel Store, multiple places to eat and many other shops.
No pets and No Smoking - Available 10/1/25
$3,000 per month rent + $3,000 security deposit required.
Utilities included Heat and Water. Pay your own Electric and Internet
Professionals Only - References/Employment/etc will be checked
Good for single or a couple.
457 Lake Ave
Saint James, NY 11780
Apartment building
1-2 beds
Available units
This building may have units for rent or for sale. Select a unit to contact.
What's special
Neighborhood: 11780
- Family VibesWarm atmosphere with family-friendly amenities and safe, welcoming streets.Outdoor ActivitiesAmple parks and spaces for hiking, biking, and active recreation.Beach AccessEasy coastal access for swimming, sunbathing, and seaside relaxation.Commuter FriendlyStreamlined routes and connections make daily commuting simple.
Set in Long Island’s North Shore, 11780 (St. James) mixes small‑town charm with coastal access. It’s family‑ and pet‑friendly. Expect four true seasons and breezy summers near Smithtown Bay and the Nissequogue River. Lake Avenue’s walkable strip offers Soul Brew coffee, family‑run Italian and seafood spots, bakeries, and delis, while bigger errands are easy at Smith Haven Mall, Whole Foods, Trader Joe’s, and Route 347 centers. Outdoor time is a staple: Gaynor Park, Caleb Smith State Park Preserve, Blydenburgh County Park’s dog area, Smithtown Landing golf, and nearby Short Beach and Long Beach for sunsets, paddling, and beach walks. The 19th‑century St. James General Store nods to the hamlet’s roots, with arts and museums minutes away in Stony Brook and Port Jefferson. Commuters use the LIRR St. James station and Routes 25A/347 for connections to the Long Island Expressway (LIE). Recent Zillow market trends show median rent in the mid‑$3,000s, with most listings over the past few months ranging roughly from the mid‑$2,000s to mid‑$4,000s.
Powered by Zillow data and AI technology.
Areas of interest
Use our interactive map to explore the neighborhood and see how it matches your interests.
Travel times
Nearby schools in Saint James
GreatSchools rating
- 6/10Saint James Elementary SchoolGrades: K-5Distance: 0.2 mi
- 6/10Nesaquake Middle SchoolGrades: 6-8Distance: 1.4 mi
- 9/10Smithtown High School EastGrades: 9-12Distance: 1 mi
Frequently asked questions
What is the walk score of 457 Lake Ave?
457 Lake Ave has a walk score of 81, it's very walkable.
What schools are assigned to 457 Lake Ave?
The schools assigned to 457 Lake Ave include Saint James Elementary School, Nesaquake Middle School, and Smithtown High School East.
What neighborhood is 457 Lake Ave in?
457 Lake Ave is in the 11780 neighborhood in Saint James, NY.
