Skip main navigation

    • 3 Madison St

    Sag Harbor, NY 11963

    Apartment building
    3 beds

    Available units

    This building may have units for rent. Select a unit to contact.
    $7,500
    3 bd, 1.5 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent

    Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate

    What's special

    Separate kitchenLight filled apartmentStainless steel appliances
    Enjoy this beautifully renovated floor through third floor apartment in the heart of Sag Harbor. This light filled apartment is 1215 sq/ft. and is in an Historic Building built in 1840 and fully renovated. The apartment offers 3 bedrooms, a separate kitchen and two generous rooms for living and dining. There is also a 550 sq/ft attic available. Stainless steel appliances, washer and dryer in unit, very large yard with grilling area, 4 garage spaces and plenty of parking round out the offering. The outbuilding is a detached 1139 sq/ft structure.

    Neighborhood: 11963

    Skip to the end of the carousel
    • Historic Area
      Rich history reflected in architecture, landmarks, and charming old-town character.
      Arts Scene
      Galleries, murals, and cultural venues showcase creativity and artistic talent.
      Beach Access
      Easy coastal access for swimming, sunbathing, and seaside relaxation.
      Dining Scene
      From casual bites to fine dining, a haven for food lovers.
    Skip to the beginning of the carousel

    Sag Harbor (11963) blends a historic whaling-village core with bayside living on Shelter Island Sound and Noyack Bay. Expect four true seasons with ocean-moderated summers, golden fall light, and quiet shoulder months. Main Street and Long Wharf anchor daily life: grab coffee at SagTown or Grindstone, shop indie boutiques, and catch films at the restored Sag Harbor Cinema or performances at Bay Street Theater. Dining ranges from oysters and sushi at Sen to classic evenings at The American Hotel, with markets like Schiavoni’s and Provisions for everyday staples, and fitness options such as Yoga Shanti and Sag Harbor Gym. Outdoor days revolve around Havens Beach, Foster Memorial (Long) Beach, sailing, paddleboarding, and easy bike loops through North Haven and the Long Pond Greenbelt; Mashashimuet Park adds fields and playgrounds. The vibe is friendly and pet‑welcoming, mixing year‑round creatives and families with seasonal visitors. Recent Zillow market trends for 11963 show a seasonally dynamic median rent and a broad price range, from compact village rentals to high‑end waterfront homes.

    Powered by Zillow data and AI technology.

    Areas of interest

    Use our interactive map to explore the neighborhood and see how it matches your interests.

    Travel times

    Walk, Transit & Bike Scores

    Nearby schools in Sag Harbor

    GreatSchools rating

    Frequently asked questions

    What schools are assigned to 3 Madison St?

    The schools assigned to 3 Madison St include Sag Harbor Elementary School and Pierson Middle High School.

    What neighborhood is 3 Madison St in?

    3 Madison St is in the 11963 neighborhood in Sag Harbor, NY.