Skip main navigation

    • Bay View Apartments

    910 S Elgin Ave, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235

    Located in Sturgeon Bay zip code 54235
    Apartment building
    Pet-friendly
    Surface parking lot
    Air conditioning available
    Shared laundry
    10–unit building
    840–1,050 sqft
    1–3 bedrooms
    1–2 bathrooms

    What's special

    BAY VIEW APARTMENTS is located at 910 S Elgin Avenue STURGEON BAY, WI and is managed by Premier Real Estate Management L.L.C., a reputable property management company with verified listings on RENTCafe. BAY VIEW APARTMENTS offers 1 to 3 bedroom apartments ranging in size from 840 to 1050 sq.ft. Amenities include Air Conditioner, Laundry Facilities, Off Street Parking, On-Site Management, Refrigerator and more. This rental community is pet friendly, welcoming both cats and dogs. Property is located in the 54235 ZIP code.

    Facts, features & policies

    Building Amenities

    Other
    • Shared: Laundry
    Services & facilities
    • On-Site Management

    Unit Features

    Appliances
    • Refrigerator
    Cooling
    • Air Conditioning: Air Conditioner

    Policies

    Parking
    • Off Street Parking: Surface Lot
    Lease terms
    • 12
    Pets
    Dogs
    • Allowed
    • 2 pet max
    • 60 lbs. weight limit
    • $250 pet deposit
    • $25 monthly pet fee
    • Restrictions: Spayed/Neutered
    • Pet deposit & monthly pet rent amounts are per animal. Breed restrictions do apply.
    Cats
    • Allowed
    • 2 pet max
    • 20 lbs. weight limit
    • $250 pet deposit
    • $25 monthly pet fee
    • Restrictions: Spayed/Neutered
    • Pet deposit & monthly pet rent amounts are per animal.

    Neighborhood: 54235

    Skip to the end of the carousel
    • Historic Area
      Rich history reflected in architecture, landmarks, and charming old-town character.
      Water Sports
      Opportunities for kayaking, paddleboarding, and aquatic adventures.
      Outdoor Activities
      Ample parks and spaces for hiking, biking, and active recreation.
      Dining Scene
      From casual bites to fine dining, a haven for food lovers.
    Skip to the beginning of the carousel

    Centered on Sturgeon Bay, this zip blends maritime history and small-town warmth with four-season Door County beauty. Expect lake-breeze summers, colorful autumns, and snowy winters, plus easy highway access via 42/57 and a walkable downtown anchored by the Door County Maritime Museum and Lighthouse Tower, the historic Michigan Street steel bridge, and Third Avenue shops. Recent Zillow market trends show a median rent around $1,300, with most listings over the past few months ranging roughly $950 to $2,200. Daily conveniences include Pick 'n Save and Walmart Supercenter; coffee at Kick Coffee, 5th and Jefferson, or Door County Coffee and Tea Co.; and dining at Sonny's Pizzeria, Bluefront Cafe, and Inn at Cedar Crossing, with local pours from Bridge Up and Starboard Brewing. Outdoor lovers enjoy Sunset and Otumba parks, Crossroads at Big Creek trails, Potawatomi State Park, and easy access to kayaking, sailing, and fishing on the bay. The vibe is friendly and pet-welcoming, with family-oriented events, galleries, theater, and low-key nightlife.

    Powered by Zillow data and AI technology.

    Areas of interest

    Use our interactive map to explore the neighborhood and see how it matches your interests.

    Building Location

    Walk, Transit & Bike Scores

    36 / 100
    Car-Dependent
    47 / 100
    Somewhat Bikeable

    Nearby schools in Sturgeon Bay

    GreatSchools rating

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the walk score of Bay View Apartments?

    Bay View Apartments has a walk score of 36, it's car-dependent.

    What schools are assigned to Bay View Apartments?

    The schools assigned to Bay View Apartments include Sawyer Elementary School, Sunrise Elementary School, and Walker Middle School.

    Does Bay View Apartments have in-unit laundry?

    No, but Bay View Apartments has shared building laundry.

    What neighborhood is Bay View Apartments in?

    Bay View Apartments is in the 54235 neighborhood in Sturgeon Bay, WI.

    What are Bay View Apartments's policies on pets?

    Dogs are allowed, with a maximum weight restriction of 60lbs. A maximum of 2 dogs are allowed per unit. To have a dog at Bay View Apartments there is a required deposit of $250. This building has monthly fee of $25 for dogs. Cats are allowed, with a maximum weight restriction of 20lbs. A maximum of 2 cats are allowed per unit. To have a cat at Bay View Apartments there is a required deposit of $250. This building has monthly fee of $25 for cats.

    There are currently no available units for Bay View Apartments on Zillow. Find rental availability at nearby or similar apartment buildings below.
    Do you manage this property?

    Claiming gives you access to insights and data about this property.